Its been a long time since i read the book or saw the movie, tim, so unfortunately i cant agree or disagree with your summation. I think we all know which is better, heres what i think. Movie part 1 march 21, 2014 march 21, 2014 harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off. The hogwarts student return to school in september. Harry potter month is a yearly event taking place throughout the month of july, to coincide with harry potters birthday. Harry, ron and hermine are almost at the end of their journey. Haithere in movies, a lot of times, brilliantly developed characters fail to impress because of the actors inability to perform the role. As his 11th birthday approaches he learns that he is in fact a wizard and his parents were not killed in a car crash as he has been told all his life but. Film adaptations usually ruin the book, as the filmmakers edit the. Apart from narrating the storyline in depth, books explain the thoughts going through a characters minds while performing an action, which lets you connect with them better and immerse yourself deeper in the story. In the 7th book, harry remembers this and realizes that the tiara is one of the horcruxes. The philosophers stone harry potter is 11 years old and living with his mean auntie, uncle and cousin in a small house in surrey, more specifically in the cupboard under the stairs. There will be themed posts, discussions, art and fans rereading the books and rewatching the movies, all of which will earn.
Nonetheless, the book is pretty good, and the movie is flatout awful. The brains behind the films were already struggling to fit harry potter and the goblet of fire into one movie. What plot points are missing in the harry potter movies that. I can say, however, that ive seen lousy books made into wonderful movies, and wonderful books made into lousy movies but when an author and a director both score a hit with the same story we, the audience, are truly fortunate. A few months ago, i shared which harry potter movie scenes should have been in the books. After movie makes major changes to the book and makes it. There were talks initially of making harry potter and the goblet of fire into two movies since the book is more than 700 pages, but the filmmakers opted instead to cut some of the background. They managed to alleviate this with the final book, by. Harry potter and the chamber of secrets book vs movie add a difference.
But in first year, when ron calls hermione a loser, harry says nothing. A month later, in october, the students from beauxbaton and durmstrang arrive in preparation the goblet of fire. Harry potter scenes that the movie got wrong youtube. Feb 14, 2016 unless you want a phoenix clawing you eyes, never question dumbledore. In the film, sirius shows him the picture in a back room at kings cross and harry is shown being somehow happy about seeing them. Differences between harry potter and the chamber of secrets. The novel was released on july 18, 2006 isbn 1400043875. However, it is apparently also possible to do so in the form of a tear as it was shown in the film, where harry scooped it up in a phial handed to him by hermione, as opposed to the book, where she conjures it from thin air. Differences between harry potter and the goblet of fire book. That would be the ruins, by scott smith, last heard from in 1993 a simple plan, later filmed by sam raimi from smiths. Movie harry will tell movie ron to do something that ron volunteered to do in the books.
Why take the risk by returning the wand to dumbledores grave when you can destroy the wand once and for all. Ive got my fingers crossed that sometime later this decade hell write another one and maybe itll turn out to be the greatest scifi epic ive ever read. Harry potter book plots left out of the movies variety. Throughout the entire book series and movies, the dursleys are terrible to harry. Harry potter fanatics know that there is a world of difference between the magical books and their respective film adaptations. This is my comparison of the harry potter books and movies. His comedic portrait of a world gone mad with extremists, from knotheads to bantus, fits with todays partisan divide in so many ways.
Differences between the book and film the chronicles of. In 4th year, when ron calls hermione ugly, harry says nothing. While reading the book i felt jack was a close friend and i started caring for him. Harry is able to show the audience that he doesnt want the elder wand for selfish reasons and make sure that no one else will use it. Film, childrens book, childrens fiction, harry potter, harry potter and the philosophers stone, j. Considering that, i figured i should give the books the credit they deserve. Harry potter and the goblet of fire that was not in the book. The escalating nightmare of the groups fate evolves inexorably from their personalities, in a way reminiscent of greek tragedy, so smith couldnt get away with the flimsy figurines that populate more genre fiction.
In harry potter and the sorcerers stone, harry, an orphan, lives with the dursleys, his horrible aunt and. While i didnt expect to be first in line for the final harry potter movie, at 11 p. There are plenty of harry potter booktofilm changes im still not over. When i was 11, i read harry potter and the sorcerers stone for the first time.
Harry doesnt want to use the elder wand or let it fall into the wrong hands. Differences between harry potter books and movies popsugar tech. But everyone now knows that the elder wand belonged to dumbledore. This post is a comparison of major plot points in the movie and book versions of harry potter and the deathly hallows pt.
In the book, harry sees the trials of the lestranges and barty crouch jr. Mar 28, 2014 in the movie, harry, hermione and ron only have to get past fluffy, through the room with the flying keys, and the chess game before harry gets to the final room with quirrell. In the films penultimate scene on the bridge, a lot is dealt with. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban this unnecessary object was added to the knight bus. I didnt see any significant differences between book ron and movie ron. Film is a column comparing books to the film adaptations they spawn, often discussing them on a. In the book, snape gives harry his memories with his wand as is the norm. In the movie, harry finds crouch when he is with ron, hermione, and hagrid. After the book was devoured i bingewatched the two films it was turned into. How different are the harry potter movies from the books. The movies actually start out following the books pretty well.
In the movie, harry, hermione and ron only have to get past fluffy, through the room with the flying keys, and the chess game before harry gets to the final room with quirrell. Jul, 2015 book ginny vs movie ginny i know that this topic has been discussed at length and im sure that a million people have done so better than me, but all the same, ive been wanting to vent about this since i started my blog so what better time to do so than harry potter month. Scott smiths wrote one of my favorite crime novels with a simple plan that released in 1993. Rowlings first harry potter novel appear in the 2001 film adaptation, theres even exact replication of. They blame him for everything and shun his magical ability, so its not surprising that they are widely disliked. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban book and movie differences were adding in differences as we find them, but if you notice that weve left something out, please email us at corrections.
In 3rd yearyo, when draco calls hermione a mudblood, harry says nothing. In the first movie, the sorcerers stone, nearly everything is just like its book counterpart. However, in the film, it shows that ginny hides the diary, thus messing the whole thing up. The ruins is ruthlessly frank about how most of us really behave in extremis. This is essentially the same meaning as in the book, but simpler for audiences and quicker to show. Harry discovers a diary written by a boy named tom riddle which has the power to transport him back in time to view his parents at his age along with a young and slightly creepy professor snape and dumbledore. The chamber of secrets focuses on a legend at hogwarts about a chamber that will unearth all sorts of evils if someone managed to open it. Book hermione had very clear flaws that the movie version didnt have. The pevensies deduce that they are in the ruins of cair paravel much more quickly in the film than in the book. The book fits specifically into the survival horror genre, which is marked by people doing whatever it takes to conquer their environment and stay alive. There are spoilers of major scenes, events and deaths. Because of the constant change of the directing staff it was impossible to create a complete picture.
The ruins is the book of the summer because, put simply, its so good that itll ruin every other book s chances. Harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off. A lot of little moments where ron defends harry are omitted. Logan lerman was about five years older than percy shoulda been in both the lightning thief and the sea of monsters. Whether because they split the final book in half or its just one of the easiest to translate to the screen, harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 is the movie most loyal to the book its. Its not that i expect every book moment to be there, but there are so many smaller moments where ron tells malfoy to shove off, defending him from snape, or even telling hermione to lay off harry. In the book, harry hides the halfblood princes potions book in a cupboard, and places the bust of a warlock on top of it, then adorns it with a wig and a tiara. Read on to find out what i think about harrys final adventure. Dec 28, 2007 harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban book and movie differences were adding in differences as we find them, but if you notice that weve left something out, please email us at corrections. Film is a column comparing books to the film adaptations they spawn, often discussing them on a plotpointbyplotpoint basis. In 19971998, when harry stupidly follows bathildanagini, hermione barely saved his life, but in the process destroys his wand. In the book, when harry touched quirrell, quirrells skin only blistered wherever harry touched. Dec 29, 2007 harry potter and the goblet of fire book and movie differences we are constantly updating these pages, so if you see something that were missing please feel free to send us an email at. Even though i am partial to movies, the books are amazing and that is saying a lot because i have never been a reader.
Read it and watch the movie to choose what is best harry. Jul 17, 2011 in the book, snape gives harry his memories with his wand as is the norm. In the book, there are two more challenges a troll, which has already been knocked out when the three get to him, and a set of potions by snape, along with a riddle that they must figure out in order to know which to drink to go on. The escalating nightmare of the groups fate evolves inexorably from their personalities, in a way reminiscent of greek tragedy, so smith couldnt get away with the flimsy figurines that. Book harry has a more takecharge attitude but is significantly more whiney. In the film, harry kills quirrell by grabbing his face, causing him to turn to dust.
This has always been amusing to me in the book the sorcerersphilosophers stone neville goes into the woods with harry, hermione, draco and hagrid in the ssps. What plot points are missing in the harry potter movies. Harry potter booksmovies differences quiz by benjid. So in the book, hermione wrings her hands in a sudden panic and ron reminds her to light one of. In the film, harry only sees his parents standing beside him in the mirror of erised, but in the book harry sees his entire extended family standing behind him in the mirror. In the book, there are two more challenges a troll, which has already been knocked out when the three get to him, and a set of potions by snape, along with a riddle. Jul 15, 2011 i dont think harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 overall is better than the book for me, none of the movies are ever going to reach that mark but these 10 individual moments. In the following years, three massive tomes were added to the series. Top ten reasons why books are better than movies thetoptens.
After movie makes major changes to the book and makes it better. Harry potter and the chamber of secrets that was not in. Dec 01, 2016 harry potter fanatics know that there is a world of difference between the magical books and their respective film adaptations. Harry potter movies were made under rowlings personal observation. Walker percys love in the ruins may have more relevance now than when he wrote it in 1971. Trapped in the mexican jungle, a group of friends stumble upon a creep. To me, the experience of reading is very different compared to watching a movie.
The movie starts out with harry in the room on the night of uncle vernons business party. Even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. However, the movies skipped over dudleys one moment of redemption. Harry potter book scenes that never made it into the movies subscribe for more thethings.
The ruins is a horror novel by american author scott smith, set on mexicos yucatan peninsula. Hermiones hair is frizzy, like its supposed to be, ron looks like i imagined him, but j. After originally started out as fanfiction written about one direction band member harry styles and published by todd on wattpad. Mar 21, 2014 harry potter and the order of phoenix. Jan 27, 2016 this is my comparison of the harry potter books and movies. Harry potter and the philosophers stone ps1 any% by torelehmann. The harry potter movies have their benefits, but most book fans would rather be reading.
In the book version of goblet of fire, rita skeeter is an unregistered animagus, who can turn into a beetle to eavesdrop on harry and his friends. When the first harry potter movie was being developed, only four books in the series had been released. Oct 16, 20 even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. Only a true potterhead will get 2020 on this books and. I have read the books and watched the films of both harry potter and.
I know the movies have skewered how people think of harry. In the book, no mention is made of minotaurs fighting for caspian, and two other species wolves and black dwarves who fought for the white witch are expressly mentioned as unviable. In the book, madeye moody shows harry a picture of the original order of the phoenix in n. Jessica couperthwaite i believe that they took harry to the leaky cauldron before going to hogwarts because they had already included the dursleys in quite a significant potion on the introduction. Back around the time it was released in 2006, stephen king praised the ruins as the best horror novel of the new century.
354 20 1068 179 731 510 701 847 47 1186 1387 1282 1012 794 1116 518 942 19 1519 898 1297 663 578 419 913 521 1339 1143 684 118 1256